The Undercutting of Rosie and Adam by Megan Bannen Series: Hart and Mercy #3
Published by Orbit on July 8, 2025
Genres: Fantasy, Romantasy
Pages: 432
Buy on Amazon, Barnes & Noble, or Bookshop.org
Find on Goodreads
From the author of The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy comes a new heartwarming fantasy rom-com with an opposites-attract twist set in the delightful, donut- and dragon-filled world of Tanria.
Immortal demigod Rosie Fox has been patrolling Tanria for decades, but lately, the job has been losing its luster. When Rosie dies (again) by electrocution (again) after poking around inside a portal choked with shadowy thorns, she feels stuck in the rut that is her unending life.
The portal's uptight creator, Adam Lee, must come in person to repair the damage. But when all the portals break down at once, Rosie and Adam wind up trapped inside the Mist. And the reticent inventor in his bespoke menswear seems to know a lot more about what's happening than he lets on.
Maybe two people who have found themselves stuck in this thorny, tangled life together can find a way to unstick each other ... just when their time on this earth seems to be running out.
The Undercutting of Rosie and Adam tries very hard to make its demi-god main character, Rosie, likeable and relatable, but it falls woefully short with its six foot five beauty. Though Rosie is supposed to be every bit as fiery as her red hair and eyes, I just found her to be rather flat. I wanted to like her, I really did, but the biggest conflict in her life can be boiled down to the fact that she has daddy issues (her dad’s one of the oldest gods, the Trickster), and that she can’t die, or rather, stay dead. This is an important distinction to make as Rosie can, in fact, die (and experience all of the pain that goes with whatever situation caused said death), but she can’t stay deceased. Instead, she’s doomed to get back up again and again, and to watch everyone she cares about pass on without her for the rest of eternity.
“No one would ever grieve Rosie. It was like that saying about always being a bridesmaid and never a bride, except she was always the mourner, never the mourned.”
She spends a lot of her time moping about it. She informs readers that she’s tried relationships before, only to watch her lovers grow old and die. Her mother is long gone and her dad pops in when it’s convenient for the god to play the victim to his daughter. Seeing as there’s no one who can really relate to her whole immortality thing, it’s no wonder that she’s tired. But we never see her refusing to get attached with anyone or becoming cold. The Undercutting of Rosie and Adam basically starts with her attending a funeral, as if to establish how awful it is that Rosie will never get to die like everyone else.
I know I am supposed to feel bad for her, but I just could never quite manage it, even with the funeral or her multiple painful deaths in the books. Other novels like The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue manage to create a much more sympathetic portrayal of what it means to have eternal life. And there really isn’t a whole lot else to Rosie other than her rather brazen love of lingerie and hatred of her work uniform.
I’m not trying to call Rosie shallow, but I did struggle to suspend my disbelief at her ability to compartmentalize a few hundred years of trauma from watching loved ones die. This disconnect was especially noticeable when she fondly recalls her time at a traveling circus, where her entire act consisted of dying and coming back to life repeatedly for an audience. The other deaths Rosie experiences on the page are portrayed as intensely painful, both physically and emotionally, which made it surprising that she never flashes back to particularly excruciating past deaths when she dies again. This tonal inconsistency undercuts the weight of her immortality, making it harder to fully engage with her emotional experience. And that’s setting aside the uncomfortable implications of the circus itself, which invites uneasy comparisons to historical “freak shows” that profited from exploiting people with real disabilities.
This immortal woman truly lives by the creed that nothing really matters because everyone will a) die and/or b) forget (depending on which comes first). I found Twyla Banneker from the previous book, The Undermining of Twyla and Frank, a chronic over-functioner desperate to prove her worth and earn love, far more compelling and relatable. There was very little in Rosie for me personally to connect with—especially as someone who considers one of the best parts of the day to be taking off my bra. I quickly grew tired of the novel’s fixation on Rosie’s underwear, though I suppose the fashion-forward might enjoy it more than I did.
“Act first, think never, because fifty years from now, no one is going to remember this anyway….”
Unfortunately, Rosie’s lack of emotional depth also weakens the central romance. But surely the male lead makes up for the somewhat “mid” heroine, right? Not really. I like a stoic, working man who is a leading expert on portals as much as the next girl, but the mutual attraction between these two is apparent from the get-go, and as a slow-burn girlie, that just didn’t really hit the sweet spot for me. And seeing as Adam had even less character development, dialogue, and page time, and was pretty much reduced to his sex appeal to Rosie, I didn’t find a whole lot to endear him to me either.
There is a moment where Rosie helps Adam face one of his deepest, darkest fears, that should have been a huge, impactful moment. But the build up just wasn’t there. The bond between the two didn’t really feel earned for me. When one character doesn’t want to talk about something, the other simply says, “okay,” and drops it. While this is respectful and I appreciate it, the sheer lack of pushback or tension between the two meant that there was little impact. Especially when the same taboo topic is brought up relatively soon after the initial conversation and suddenly now it’s not only time for the characters to share, but also is apparently easy to confide—it feels a little silly to worry about any potential consequences for the short lived reticence of the characters.
And everything is always just so easy for Rosie and Adam. They seem to perfectly understand one another with very little actual conversation or connection. Call me crazy, but to me, enjoying each other’s taste in clothing or vehicles is really not a solid foundation for a relationship. So when the big moment of Rosie forcing Adam to confront his fears came around, I had this feeling of, “well, of course he told Rosie about his fear and she is the one who helps him move past it with practically zero effort or concern for his feelings.” Of course he doesn’t at all resent her for subjecting him to it without his explicit consent or much, if any, preparation. He just takes some time to himself to recover and gets over it. While readers eventually discover that Rosie and Adam have more in common than even they knew, it’s kind of astounding that the relationship is clearly a feast made of breadcrumbs.
“‘You don’t have to worry about a gal who can’t die.’
‘Do you think you don’t merit concern because you cannot die?’”
Even when reading a romantasy, I do enjoy the feeling of “will-they-won’t-they.” Obviously it’s clear when a book has the name of two characters in the title, that they are intended to end up together. However, there was a microscopic amount of “won’t they” in this equation. Even with Rosie immortal and constantly lamenting her inability to die when everyone else around her does, there is never any doubt in her mind that she should get with Adam. She doesn’t worry about watching him age, having to put him in a nursing home, or anything. She spends more time worrying about the smell of his cologne, his height (or lack thereof—manz is a short king), or trading handkerchiefs with him. And I know the bar for romantic partners is in hell, but the novel presents one of Adam’s biggest selling points as the fact that he doesn’t want Rosie taking unnecessary risks simply because he can’t bear to watch her be in pain and die over and over again—something framed less as basic human concern and more as proof that he is her destined soulmate, meant to change her outlook on eternal life.
Unfortunately, the emotional impact for the characters and the romance as a whole just wasn’t there for me, and I didn’t exactly read this book for the fantasy setting, either. Though the series does have very interesting concepts with its Old and New Gods, they seem more like plot devices most of the time than actual parts of the characters’ day lives. It must be said though that I absolutely love the world’s animal/human mail carriers, dubbed nimkilim. This novel has another standout postal worker and I can’t help but to wish that our own world’s postal workers were also cute animals. The portrayal of dragons was also a delight, just as it was in the series’ predecessor.
The major dilemma of The Undercutting of Rosie and Adam, is a massive overgrowth of plants that are breaking Tanria’s portals, and have trapped people outside of the mist, and unable to get back to civilization. Thankfully, Adam is some kind of genius, and an expert portal fixer. Rosie and her partner in the Marshalls, who readers will recognize from the other novels, Duffers, are also trapped on the wrong side, along with Duffers’s ex-boyfriend, Zeddie Birdsall (brother to the female main character in the first book, Mercy). This is probably a no-brainer, but I just wasn’t as invested in this major plot point (which is quite obviously a tool for forced proximity between Adam and Rosie), as I was in the previous novel’s, which involved baby dragons who sneeze glitter.
Anyways, the evil plant overgrowth also didn’t give me any feelings of urgency. Seeing as the cast of characters didn’t seem too bothered about the dwindling supplies of food (they were actually dining on insanely delicious meals cooked by chef Zeddie), and had shelter, it was a little hard to feel the danger. Plus even after Rosie worries about how long three mortals can live without deliveries, she quickly brushes it aside and delights in a delivery of her Very Important Undergarments. Rosie, Adam, Duffers, and Zeddie seem to think it was only a matter of time until they could fix the portals and leave Tanria. Though Zeddie and Duffers have a moment or two of short lived meltdowns when their hopes of going home are initially dashed, they get over it with an insane amount of aplomb. As someone who hates being without Wi-Fi and has anxiety about the little things like parking situations—the prospect of slowly starving to death after being cut off from the world, technology, and everyone I loved—I just couldn’t understand how well they were coping. So it’s no surprise that I also had no doubt that the characters would work everything out in the end, and in a way that probably actually benefited the world later on too.
Readers who enjoy easily fought for happy endings, light romance reads, particularly with love (or lust) at first sight, and some fantasy elements, will probably really enjoy The Undercutting of Rosie and Adam. Though I found it to be an entertaining read and had no trouble picking the novel back up, I would say this is by far the weakest entry in the trilogy for me personally. I will still definitely check out the author’s future works and will be excited to see what she comes up with next, but that’s based more on my reading experience with the previous novels in the series. It was really nice to see all of the characters of all the books get their happy endings (even though there are timeskips involved, which is not ideal for me), and I think The Undercutting of Rosie and Adam could be read by existing fans of the series or new readers.
This post may contain affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.














Robin has read and reviewed these. Sorry this one was just ok.
Anne – Books of My Heart
That’s okay, it was still a fun read. I don’t know about Robin, but I’m personally so glad these types of books are becoming more popular! 🤭💙